There is absolutely nothing wrong with compacts/phones, as I have stated before I do use a compact at times and before I bought a DSLR it was my entry level camera into the Digital age. [in celluloid days I did start with a SLR, at the top you could say, and worked my way down, with a LOT of fails, 5 in 500 were not good averages and expensive in celluloid.]
[linked pic] is from said same Compact. I love this shot, I was actually hunting the sunset, the sun had gone down, so I thought? Upon leaving where I was, driving away, the sunset became more stunning than any of 90 shots taken in the last half hour?
While I love the pic, my opinion is it fails with the sun dead smack bang in the center?
[linked pic]https://www.allombo.com/p/00/00/06/669083658.jpg[/url] This pic is a direct copy from a 25 year old celluloid transparency taken using a SLR camera.
[linked pic] This one ? AHEM! A DLSR, pointed direct south, the sun does not set in the south, heavily edited, and being a pic I took, as I am my own worst critic, CRAP!!!
The blurble above and examples, I hope demonstrate, there are basic 'guidelines' to photography that do make photos more or less appealing, no matter what camera is used? One of these is 'Rule of Thirds'. Yes even camera makers include a "Grid" that you can turn on or off that divides the screen in to ..... wait for it ..... Thirds. [center spot auto focus destroys this, unless you half hold the shutter to auto focus, then shift the subject in the frame, before releasing the shutter.]
I am by nature a very symmetrical person, hence the thirds go against my very inherent nature, the first pic shows thirds top to bottom, yet not side to side, thats the reason to me that is fails my eye as a picture? Even if the color pops. [OldmanEmu, thats "vivid setting"]
The middle one, obvious in those years with no instant review/editing, I may have taken more time to Compose it?
The third one ..... AHEM!! DSLR or not is not going to matter, its not a good photo.
An exercise in photography was to use a cardboard disposable camera, they had a shutter button, thats it! The art was in composure, lighting and all the very basic ''Guidelines'' that could make or break a photograph. Another exercise was the moon, this yielded a lot of white blobs, why? The moon is 100% reflected full sun light, so, even though its night, one must use shutter and aperture as though in daylight.
I am not perfect, I do get disgusted at my own work, or my own impatience when I think I should have got it right.